Jovan Belcher Tragedy: Football Players and Violence

Jovan Belcher Tragedy: Football Players and Trauma

Jovan Belcher murder suicide: Another football tragedy. Image by Jeffrey Beall

It’s happened again. On December 1, Jovan Belcher of the Kansas City Chiefs shot his girlfriend, the mother of his child, and then publicly turned the gun on himself . In May of 2012, Junior Seau of the San Diego Chargers died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound. In February, 2011, Dave Duerson who formerly played with both the Chicago Bears and New York Giants took his own life.

Football stars rank high in the American pantheon. Why would these men, who seemingly had lived the American Dream, commit such acts?

Jovan Belcher Tragedy

Jovan Belcher played football for the Kansas City Chiefs, and USA Today reports that he was actually a member of the campus initiative, “Male Athletes Agains Violence” at the University of Maine. On December 1, however, he killed Kasandra Perkins (the mother of his baby) and then went on to kill himself in front of his coach and general manager.

Link to Concussions and Brain Injury?

The Belcher tragedy raises questions about football and brain injury. After the Duerson suicide, the football player’s brain was examined by neuropathologist Dr. Ann McKee, who found Duerson’s brain had three large holes. McKee was quoted as saying, “I would assume that with this amount of damage the person was very cognitively impaired.”

As early as 2010, the New York Times reported that head injuries and concussions were dangerous. In that article, a 2007 study was cited that found that of the NFL players who had suffered a concussion, “20.2 percent said they had been found to have depression.” Additionally, the New York Times article stated that Alzheimer’s disease is 19 times more common in football players.

Click to Read Page Two: Football’s Culture of Violence

Pages: 1 2

Ted

Other sports writers have commented that Jovan Belcher has no known concussion history.

It is a good thing to recognize that mental problems are arising among NFL players who are known to have suffered brain-injuries. However, to imply that the mere participation in the sport should be linked to pathological behavior, in the absence of known injury or clinical data, is a whole different thing.

The link between concussions and behavior-problems is legit and ought to be pursued. Trying to link behavior-problems to merely playing football, to aggression in general or to physicality … this is casting the net too-wildly, implies too much at too great a distance from the solid investigative base.

How will you react, if it is found that marijuana residue is present in Mr. Belcher’s residence and personal effects? Will you then ascribe his murderous conduct to, say, “marijuana madness”?
Gina Putt

Note that the article does not state that Belcher had brain injury, only that it is a possiblity given the statistics about the sport. Undiagnosed concussions are possible. The choice to commit suicide is most likely multifactorial. Drugs in the bloodstream; alcohol included might be contributing factors – we won’t know for a while.
Ted

This article is still the “Featured” piece on the Google News Sports listing.

I previously (mis-)took it as actual sports-commentary, but now, reading the author’s by-line, I see it is written from a professional academic, scientist’s viewpoint.

Although head-injuries (brain-damage) in football is an important matter, and most are now glad to see it getting responsible attention, neither football nor the NFL franchise pioneered concussion-tolerance and resulting health/mental issues. Boxing, for example, makes the infliction of concussion the center-piece of the sport.

Gun-deaths are of little use to gun-oppenents, because half of them are suicides, and guns are the tool-of-choice, for those who commit suicide. Brain-trauma is statistically of zero significance, in suicide epidemiology.

Belcher and his partner, whom he murdered, had a ‘troubled’ relationship. This is one of the highest risk-factors anywhere. It is well-reported that they fought the night before, and continued in the morning. All cops know, average people know, “domestic violence” is really the scary condition, the set-up for tragedy.

Belcher is described by his teammates in terms that do not suggest depression at all. His interpersonal behavior belied no changes or instabilities … as have been remarked upon, in the case of other NFL players with brain-deterioration.

The NFL, and vigorous sports in general, is not a depravity that we need to denounce & defame. Aggression per se is not a pathology; it is a normal attribute of mammals; it varies between species, and individuals. But aggression generally-speaking is an evolved trait, not a sickness.
lori

His impulsivity, nightly use of alcohol, pain medications may have been the causal trigger. His behavioral training to react quickly and violently in the work place while continually being positively reinforced for such behavior may have spilled over into his argument with his girlfriend while he was under this nightly influence that had not worn off by that tragic argumentative morning (for whatever reason due to argument qualifiers?)
While it is true, TBI is not necessarily a regular and expected injury from the workforce of football, impulsive behavioral reactions of aggression while fearful, angry and defensive outside of the workforce may trigger explosive situations. Behavioral training and constancy can produce an extreme sense of guilt, self-pity, self-hatred when not achieving and may be equally more destructive off the field when the positive reinforcement has ceased. The player needs to return to where he last received positive reinforcement and encouragement at all costs, as is the training protocol.
Beverly Rodriguez

I hope that when football players die of suicide the families decide to have the brain examined.
Much damage doesn’t show up easily.
APatriot1

Why should anyone think being an NFL player would make them immune to physical and mental illness, domestic problems or emotional duress any less than the general population? We all bleed. We all cry as well as laugh. Whatever the cause for his domestic issues, perhaps he could have gotten help or resolved it without a tragic outcome if he didn’t have a gun in the house. The same can be said about so many others who don’t have the same public visibility. I can’t say it happens everyday, but domestic violence with fatal outcomes happens way too often during the holiday season.
Gina Putt

Lori’s point that training to react quickly may increase family violence is very intriguing. I also think that Beverly makes a good point as well. As a people, we need to know more about sports injuries and how to enjoy sports without putting players at psychological risk.